Small Business Website Tips

7 Website Mistakes That Are Costing You Customers (And How to Fix Them)

Your website may look perfectly fine to you. But your customers experience it differently.

Sometimes it's the little things that make someone click, call... or quietly disappear. 💜

🎧

Rather listen than read? Hit play and we'll read this article to you.

Ready to listen

Your website doesn't have to be terrible to lose customers.

Sometimes a confusing headline, buried phone number, painfully slow page or awkward mobile layout is all it takes for a potential customer to decide: “Never mind. I'll try the next company.”

Here are seven common website mistakes worth checking on your own site — and how to fix them.

Visitors Can't Immediately Tell What You Do

Your homepage shouldn't make visitors solve a mystery.

When someone lands on your website, they should quickly understand what your business offers and whether they've come to the right place.

The problem: vague headlines such as “Welcome,” “Quality You Can Trust” or “Experience the Difference” sound nice but don't actually explain the business.

Imagine landing on a website with the headline:

“Solutions Designed for You.”

Okay... but are we buying insurance, landscaping, accounting services or llama therapy? 😂

THE FIX: Use a clear headline that tells visitors what you offer, who you help or what result you provide.

Your Website Is Painful to Use on a Phone

Your website may look gorgeous on the giant monitor sitting on your desk.

That's wonderful.

Now pull out your phone.

Can you actually use it?

The problem: tiny text, overlapping elements, microscopic buttons, cropped images and menus that refuse to cooperate can make mobile visitors give up.

Check important pages on an actual phone and look for:

Text that's easy to read without zooming
Buttons large enough to tap
Images that display properly
Forms that fit the screen
Navigation that's easy to open and use
Phone numbers that are tap-to-call

THE FIX: Don't treat mobile as a shrunken version of desktop. Review the mobile experience separately and adjust layouts where necessary.

Your Website Takes Forever to Load

People aren't famous for their patience online.

If visitors spend too long staring at a blank screen or watching giant images slowly appear one piece at a time, some will leave before they ever see your offer.

Common culprits: oversized images, unnecessary scripts, excessive animations, auto-playing media and overloaded pages.

🖼️ Optimize Images

🧹 Remove Clutter

⚡ Test Performance

THE FIX: Compress and properly size images, remove unnecessary third-party code and periodically test the performance of your most important pages.

You're Making Customers Hunt for Contact Information

A visitor has decided they want to contact you.

Congratulations!

Please don't reward them with a scavenger hunt. 😂

The problem: the phone number only appears in tiny text in the footer, the Contact page is hidden in a menu or the customer has no idea how you prefer to be contacted.

Depending on your business, important contact options might include:

Phone number
Contact form
Email address
Booking link
Quote request
Business address
Hours of operation

THE FIX: Put important contact options where customers naturally expect to find them — and make the primary contact action obvious.

There's No Clear Next Step

Your visitor read about your business.

They like what they see.

Now what?

The problem: pages simply end without telling visitors what action they should take next.

A clear C.T.A. — call to action — might invite someone to:

Request a quote
Schedule an appointment
Call your business
Shop your products
View your portfolio
Join your email list
Contact you for more information

THE FIX: Decide what the most logical next action is on each important page and make that action easy to spot.

Your Website Doesn't Give People a Reason to Trust You

Your potential customer doesn't know what you know about your business.

You know you're legitimate.

You know you do good work.

You know you're not going to take their deposit and flee the country on a speedboat.

They don't know any of that yet. 😂

The problem: the website makes claims but offers very little evidence to help a new visitor feel confident.

Trust signals may include:

Real customer reviews
Testimonials
Before-and-after photos
Portfolio examples
Years of experience
Certifications
Professional affiliations
Clear business contact information
Real photos of your team or work

THE FIX: Don't just tell customers you're good. Give them useful reasons to believe you.

Your Website Looks Abandoned

This one sneaks up on business owners.

You launch the website.

You're proud of it.

Then five years pass while you're busy actually running the business.

Suddenly your homepage is advertising a 2022 holiday sale and your About page introduces an employee who moved to Montana three years ago. 😂

The problem: outdated information can make visitors wonder whether the business is still active or whether they can trust the rest of the information on the site.

Watch for:

Old prices
Services you no longer offer
Expired promotions
Old staff information
Broken links
Incorrect hours
Outdated contact information
Old copyright dates when manually entered

THE FIX: Schedule a quick website review every few months. You don't need to redesign the whole thing — just make sure the information customers rely on is still accurate.